9 November 2026
A Field Is Not a Portfolio
Land stopped being a place you belonged to and became a thing you held, the moment someone decided it should earn a return. That shift is older than any of us, and reversing it, one plot at a time, is the whole point.
A field doesn't know it's an asset. It doesn't know its own valuation, hasn't read the land registry entry with its name on it, has no opinion on whether it's appreciating or being "underutilised." Those are things we decided about it, from the outside, long after it had already been doing its actual job — holding water, growing things, being somewhere a fox could cross without anyone minding.
Somewhere along the way, in England, a huge amount of land stopped being a place and started being a portfolio line. The Enclosure Acts are the clearest version of this, the paperwork trail where you can watch it happen in real time: commons that had fed and fuelled whole villages for generations, fenced, surveyed, and handed to whoever already owned the most of everything else. The sheep that grazed there, the fuel that got gathered there, the grandmother who knew exactly which corner of it to dig for the best soil — none of that showed up in the new valuation. It wasn't relevant to the new way of counting.
That's the actual shift worth naming, because it's not really about hedges and fences. It's about what counts. A relationship with land asks what it needs, what it's doing this season, who else depends on it, whether it's tired. An asset asks one question: what's the return. Everything else is noise to be optimised away — including, often, the people who were using the thing for the very reasons it was worth using.
We're not pretending this is only history. The same question gets asked about land constantly, right now, in exactly the same language: highest and best use, unlocking value, land banking until the market's ready. It's a quiet kind of violence, mostly, because nobody has to raise their voice to do it. You just stop asking the old questions and start asking the one question, and the land goes from being somewhere to being something.
The vision behind Rooted Common Ground Farms starts from refusing that swap. We're working towards a proposed network of community farm spaces across central England, where land is held in trust rather than held as an asset — which sounds like a technical distinction until you notice what it actually protects. An asset exists to be sold when the number is right. Something held in trust exists to keep doing its job, season after season, regardless of what the number says. The moment land is designed to be sellable-if-the-price-is-good, you've already quietly agreed that its real purpose is extraction, and everything else — the people growing food on it, the kids who learned to dig there, the person who comes every Tuesday because it's the only hour of their week nobody needs anything from them — is a nice-to-have, not the point.
We think it's the point. A plot of land that produces vegetables and also produces a Tuesday where someone feels less alone isn't underperforming because the second thing doesn't show up on a balance sheet. It's doing exactly what land is for.
None of this is us claiming to have solved it. We don't have ground in the ground yet — this is a vision we're working towards, not a finished thing, and we're honest about that. What we're certain of is the question we want to be asking when we do get there. Not "what's this worth." Something closer to: who depends on this, what does it need from us this season, and what are we holding it for.
Small and real beats a masterplan on paper, so we're not promising a network of thriving farms by next spring. We're promising that whatever gets built, gets built on the first question instead of the second one. That's the whole argument, really. Not that land should be free, or that nobody should ever hold a deed — just that somewhere underneath every decision about a piece of ground, there should be a relationship doing the deciding, not a spreadsheet.
The Enclosure Acts took that relationship away from most people, one survey at a time. Reversing it doesn't require a single dramatic gesture. It requires deciding, plot by plot, to ask the old question again.